Posted by: shannynmoore | October 16, 2008

Game. Set. Match. OBAMA!

“…this is going to be, I think, one of the most consequential decisions of the next president…”

-Barack Obama during last night’s debate referring to the next president’s Supreme Court appointments.


The Supreme Court discussion during last night’s debate was certainly one of the highlights as well as one of the most important issues of this election.  


The lasting and devastating impact of a McCain-Palin Administration would be in their Supreme Court appointments. Three of the four members of the liberal bloc-John Paul Stephens (age 88), Ruth Bader Ginsburg (age 75) and David Hackett Souter (age 69)-are expected to retire or expire during the next president’s term. By comparison, three of the four members of the conservative bloc-John Paul Roberts (age 53), Samuel Alito (age 58) and Clarence Thomas (age 60) are spring chickens by Supreme Court standards and will actively legislate from the bench for many years, perhaps decades, to come. Antonin Scalia (age 72), is a tough old Italian and not expected to leave anytime soon. John McCain is on record saying he admires and would seek justices like John Paul Roberts and Samuel Alito.


“I have my own standards of judicial ability, experience, philosophy, and temperament. And Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito meet those standards in every respect. They would serve as the model for my own nominees if that responsibility falls to me.”

John McCain May 6, 2008


Last night, McCain said he would not have a litmus test for his Supreme Court appointments and in his next labored breath claimed, “Elections have consequences.”  McCain went on, “I will find the best people in the world–in the United States of America who have a history of strict adherence to the Constitution. And not legislating from the bench.”  Really? Just like Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito?  The same Roberts and Alito who, last June, voted in the minority against restoring habeas corpus?  A McCain Administration would threaten legal cornerstones like habeas corpus. Habeas corpus is not an amendment to the Constitution, it IS the Constitution. It is the 13th Century right to challenge your detention. Our revolution against England was in large part a rejection of the disappearing citizens-shackled in dungeons, imprisoned or killed without charges. The Military Commissions Act, signed into law by Bush on October 17, 2006, suspended habeas corpus and undermined America’s rise over the tyranny we’d fought against. On June 12th of this year, the Supreme Court voted to restore habeas corpus in a 5-4 decision. Roberts and Alito led the RATS (Roberts Alito Thomas Scalia) in dissent. Dissent of the Constitution itself!  A vote for McCain is a vote for a clone of Roberts and Alito! It is a vote against the Bill of Rights and for the roll back of our civil liberties. If you trade Stephens, Ginsburg and Souter for three Roberts-Alito clones, a future court ruling on habeas corpus would permanently eliminate the right of American Citizens to challenge their detention with an 8-1 landslide and landmark decision.  Clearly, John McCain doesn’t understand the Constitution, or he is lying about nominating justices “who have a history of strict adherence to the Constitution.”


Consider the recent Exxon Valdez verdict (audio interview on the day of the ruling with Greg Palast) that somehow slipped Sarah Palin’s mind when asked to comment on Supreme Court decisions by Katie Couric. Exxon, the company that set and broke planet earth’s quarterly profit record three quarters in a row, was let off the hook. Future corporate punitive damages are now forever minimally capped because of a conservative John “What more can a corporation do?” Roberts Supreme Court! The Court based their conservative activist ruling on 19th Century Maritime Law! 21st Century Corporations can now view punitive damages as the small cost of doing business. Due to Exxon’s negligence and the corporate sympathy of the Supreme Court, one the largest acts of environmental terrorism in history was treated like an accidental littering.


But the Supreme Court discussion last night centered on Roe v. Wade.  While Roe v. Wade is an important and controversial decision, it’s also the biggest carrot the Republicans have to motivate their Christian Right base.  If the Court were to overturn it, the Republicans would potentially lose a massive funding source. It would also stifle their ground game to incite their base to vote en masse.  Abortion is also a distraction.  While the focus is on Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Court is setting precedent and making decisions empowering corporations at the People’s expense; judicially paving the way to fascism.


As an Alaskan, I am all too familiar with Sarah Palin and her blurring the line between church and state. But her potential as vice-president to influence and legislate her religious beliefs terrify me. Her “no choice” stance on abortion causes me great concern. I’m not a liberal with an abortion punch card, but I agree with Roe v. Wade. What happens in my uterus or anyone else’s is a private matter.  Last night, Barack Obama remarked,” I am completely supportive of a ban on late-term abortions, partial-birth or otherwise, as long as there’s an exception for the mother’s health and life…I’m willing to support a ban on late-term abortions as long as we have that exception.”  John McCain sarcastically retorted, ”Just again, the example of the eloquence of Senator Obama. He’s health for the mother. You know, that’s been stretched by the pro-abortion movement in America to mean almost anything. That’s the extreme pro-abortion position, quote, “health.”” What?  Excuse me? McCain’s outright mockery of the health and life of the mother as being a legitimate reason for termination was deplorable. How dare he!? Perhaps Palin has rubbed off; maybe he can now see hospitals from his many houses and is an expert in medical care. However, he’s dead wrong.  According to the CDC, the maternal mortality rate in the United States is the highest it’s been in decades.  Shame on you John McCain.


In Sarah Palin’s RNC speech, she said of Barack Obama. “Al Qaeda terrorists still plot to inflict catastrophic harm on America … he’s worried that someone won’t read them their rights?” Hard fought rights are who we are, what we stand for, what we’ll do, and what we won’t. They are not about who or what we fight. If the terrorist attacks of 9/11 were because terrorists “hate our freedom”, they will surely love us with a McCain-Palin Supreme Court. Last night, Barack mistakenly gave McCain credit for standing up to Bush on torture. John McCain caved on waterboarding. McCain, in fact, is willing to turn our service men and women into those who tortured him. He had the street cred to just say no to the Bush Administration when it came to waterboarding and FAILED! He knows it doesn’t provide accurate information, and turns men into monsters. McCain wants to be a maverick, but instead puts politics above principles; the rule of men over the rule of law.


The Supreme Court has been a motivating factor for voters in elections past. This round, however, is truly an unprecedented moment where the scales of justice are threatened; like never before. A vote for Barack Obama keeps those scales level. A vote for John McCain shifts the balance of the court to the far right for decades and threatens that which so many have given their lives for.



  1. John McCain’s “air quotes” mocking women’s health issues was disgusting. This election can’t be over fast enough for me – I want to cast my vote for Obama, help him “hang the drapes” and get on course to help America regain our integrity, economic stability and building a positive future.

  2. Shannyn for Governor of Alaska.
    Hillary for Supreme Court Justice.

    Excellent article!

  3. Brilliant, informative and important for all Americans to contemplate! Great job!

  4. My computer is having problems so I can’t verify this, but after McCain clearly claimed that a stance on Roe v Wade would not be a litmus test for choosing a Supreme Court judge, he would look at their qualifications as a judge, didn’t he say something like, “well what they think of Roe v Wade would be part of their qualifications.” And Obama shook his head in disbelief. Check it out to see if I heard correctly.

    He was not only despicable when he sneered at Obama taking into consideration “a woman’s health”, but when he sneered at the idea of “spreading wealth around”. What, to John McCain, is patriotism? Isn’t part of being an American helping those who are having trouble helping themselves? Everybody chipping in? The haves helping the have nots? What kind of country does he live in? The more we have, the more we should be thankful and give back! And how does he think we improve our schools, build stronger bridges, research the origins of diseases, create programs for special needs kids? And how does he pay for his War in Iraq? With oil?

  5. ‘spreading wealth around’… yeah, that was over the top. especially when you know that obama is just going to try to put tax policy back to where it was under clinton. and make a couple other tweaks to make social security and medicare solvent. under republican rule the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, under clinton the rich got richer and the poor got richer. that’s how it is supposed to work — a rising tide lifts all boats.

  6. McCain just can’t help himself. He was condescending, rude, dismissive, and barely contained his anger. He’s just not presidential timber.

    And there are his actual ideas and proposals. Last night may have been the beginning of the end.

    And now for a bit of humor…

  7. Was I imagining it or did McCain lump transplants with plastic surgery in regards to health care? I am sure NO company would insure my daughter with a pre-exisiting heart defect and possible need for future transplant. Without employer insurance we would be bankrupt. Maybe I could get a two for one transplant/eye lift!

  8. The moderator did ask McCain point blank if he thought Obama was a terrorist (if you listen close you can hear it over McCain interrupting) and McCain never answered.

    He can not answer because he knows the truth, Obama is not or he would not be in the Senate.
    But if finally tells the truth, McCain will show what a liar he really is.

    I would love to be a fly on the wall the day McCain and Palin have to go back to their old jobs after Nov. 4th and have to answer to all those nasty things they said.
    How do they sleep at night?

    Obama/Biden ’08

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: