Posted by: shannynmoore | October 25, 2009

Do You Have A Lightsaber, Mr. Hamilton?

Professor Rick Steiner has a challenge for this week’s “Cluster Douche” award winner, University of LukeSkywalkerAlaska President Mark Hamilton.

Too bad Hamilton hasn’t taken a cue from Palin and quit…with his upcoming retirement, he’s a lame duck president.

President Hamilton —
Given recent circumstances, I would like to invite you to debate with me, openly and publicly, re: the issue of academic freedom, and the influence of corporate donations to the university.
You have said many things in support of academic freedom over the years, but when push came to shove in my case, you made a decision in opposition to free speech.
In 2002, you received an award for your support of academic freedom from a group calling itself the “National Association of Scholars”, who it turns out, actually opposes sustainability movements on today’s college campuses.  They say that sustainability is “deceptive, coercive, closed-minded, a pseudo-religion, distorts higher education, shrinks freedom, programs people, is anti-rational, by-passes faculty, and is wasteful.”  This group apparently supports free speech only when they agree with what is spoken, and opposes it when they disagree with what is spoken.  Apparently this is your position as well.  That you chose to accept an award fro this group calls into serious question the progressive character of the University of Alaska.
All of this is an extremely serious transgression of the very role a university is supposed to fulfill in civil society.
I look forward to your reply, and to debating this issue publicly and honestly.
Sincerely, Rick Steiner, Professor


  1. Good luck with that. The Hamiltons of the world didn’t get to where they are by engaging in open debate or being open to dissenting opinions.

    Typical sense-of-entitlement B.S.

  2. duel on…….who can resist a public verbal duel?

  3. Come on Hamilton…….it’s public, it’s safe. Step up to the podium. Speak your piece.

  4. Bravo, Well said!

  5. Why would Hamilton refuse a discussion?

  6. Hope this challenge has been published in all Alaskan Newspapers.

    Love to see that debate moderated and shown on Bill Moyer’s Show, on PBS or at a leading University such as Harvard, Princeton, Stanford, Oxford. And let the audience declare the winner!

  7. I support Rick Stieners position on this issue. The TRUTH/REALITY will always prevail in the end. Anything less than TRUTH/REALITY will eventually be found to be flawed, false, or corrupted, and will either yeild or be crushed by TRUTH/REALITY.

  8. […] was taped before a live audience at Bernie’s Bungalow Lounge. This weeks guests included: Rick Steiner, Anne Kilkenny, Andrew Halcro and John Bitney. The Opening spot with Alice […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: